My Goodreads review: Mayra
Jun. 25th, 2025 04:48 pm
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
Nicky Gonzales's debut novel, Mayra, is as much about the power of teenage female friendship as it is about its dark plotline. Not that said power is always a force for good -- it certainly isn't in this case -- but its strength is undeniable. And it lasts far longer than the teen years, an undertow tugging at mundane adult life.
Set in the Cuban-American community of Hialeah, FL, Mayra is sparked by viewpoint character Ingrid (a cautious young working-class woman) getting an invitation from a childhood friend she hasn't seen in years. Mayra is everything Ingrid currently isn't: college student, confident thrill-seeker, impulse follower. She's spending a weekend with her boyfriend at a house in the Everglades -- and she'd love to reconnect. Several hours and many struggles later, Ingrid finds herself in what can only be described as a tropical Southern Gothic manor.
From this point on, the story becomes a slow-burn journey into the mystery of this house, and of Mayra's boyfriend Benji's relationship to it. Benji's a great host -- possibly to a fault. Days slip by in elaborate meals and long boozy conversations, leaving the two friends with plenty of time to explore the house, grounds, & their own shared history. There are lots of flashbacks (probably not a good read for those who prefer a strictly linear plot), culminating in Ingrid's discovery of a diary possibly kept by another woman who lived in this house decades ago.
Whether the dreamlike, hallucinatory feel of this novel gets it close enough to horror will depend upon the reader's patience, though there is some explanation late in the game. Ingrid is left with one last choice to make in her friendship with Mayra -- and Mayra herself is no help at all.
Three and a half stars, rounded up for writing quality and how many passages I highlighted. Recommended for readers looking for a very different modern Gothic, with a focus on the troubled dynamics of female friendship.
[My thanks to NetGalley, who provided me with an ARC in exchange for my honest review.]
View all my reviews