The Lost Story by
Meg ShafferMy rating:
4 of 5 stars[My thanks to NetGalley for providing me with an ARC of this novel in exchange for an honest review.]
Although this novel presents itself as a fairy tale for grown-ups -- and a very effective one -- the magical land at its heart, Shenandoah, turns out to be the creation of a thirteen-year-old girl. A very gifted, troubled thirteen year-old girl, who was kidnapped several years before the start of this novel. When her younger stepsister (separated by adoption) hires a noted missing-persons expert to find her, he turns out to have his own experience of being lost -- and his own connection to Shenandoah. He also has an artist friend who was lost with him in Shenandoah, but no longer remembers the experience. He does, however, remember how to get them all to one possible entrance.
And we're off!
This was a truly delightful reading experience -- though, like all authentic fairy tales,
The Lost Story holds its share of darkness. There is plenty of death and more than a little abuse in the back stories of these characters. The artist -- who turns out to be more than a friend to our missing-persons expert -- has unfinished business with his father. The sisters only want to stay together. No one wants to leave Shenandoah, although it offers little of the security of twenty-first century America. As the plot winds tighter, however, it becomes increasingly evident that wishes do not always come true in this enchanted place. Can a rewrite fix it?
As in Meg Shaffer's previous novel,
The Wishing Game, the characters here seem slightly off-center from our reality. This doesn't get in the way of them being immediately sympathetic. There are also several pop culture referents (Stevie Nicks,
Firefly, Trapper Keepers) which may not hold up well over time. The spirit of true storytelling, though, is another matter -- and
The Lost Story has that in spades.
Recommended for anyone in need of medicine for melancholy.
View all my reviews